B-school prof says it’s time to abolish b-schools

 B-school prof says it’s time to abolish b-schools




Education Images/Getty Images

Chomping down on the hand that feeds him, Cambridge University business school professor Chris Marquis argued that business schools shouldn’t exist, in a New York Times op-ed published this week.

Marquis, who has also taught at Harvard and Cornell, claims that unlike law or medical schools, which teach students to maximize social good, MBA programs prioritize minting high-paid managers singularly focused on profit.He cites research from Nobel-winning economist Daron Acemoglu suggesting that firms run by MBAs tend to redistribute profits from workers to shareholders, while not growing faster.
Marquis slammed b-school case studies, saying they oversimplify reality and omit negative facts about companies, while promoting buzzy management fads rather than evidence-based insights.

He proposed replacing MBAs…with multidisciplinary business programs that examine issues through a broader lens, incorporating “questions of history, democracy and ecological limits.”
There’s plenty of pushback

For instance, Copenhagen Business School professor Nicolai J. Foss seconded many of Marquis’s b-school criticisms, but argued that it might not be realistic to teach managers to prioritize social benefit, which is difficult to define and measure. He also questioned the op-ed’s implication that profit-seeking activities are divorced from producing societal value.

Regardless…the financial return on investment from many MBA programs (based on tuition and the pay bump graduates can expect) has declined over the past year, per Bloomberg’s calculations.—SK

RG Richardson Communications News

I am a business economist with interests in international trade worldwide through politics, money and banking. Interactive Internet VoIP and secure eMail Communications. The author of RG Richardson City Guides that has over 300 guides, including restaurants, real estate and finance.